Website Evaluation #5 - Wikipedia
What web browser are you using? | Explorer |
Does the site suggest that it is better viewed with one kind of web browser in particular? | No |
What is the URL of the Web page you are evaluating? | http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page |
Have a look at the domain name of the URL. How does the fact that the site is an .edu; .com; .gov; or .org influence your opinions about the site? | .org - Yes |
Who put this information here? | Special Interest Group |
Does the source of the information have any influence on your judgement about the usefulness of this site? | Yes |
How often is the site up-dated? | Updated Daily |
Can you tell when was the last time particular page/section was changed? | Yes |
Does the currency of the information have any influence on your judgement about the usefulness of this site? | Yes |
How old is the material? | Most of the material is relatively new |
Who wrote the information? | "Wikipedians" - both moderators and subscribers |
Is the author’s signature on the page? | Yes |
Is the author’s e-mail address included? | Yes |
Is there any other way of identifying the author? | Yes |
If you can’t identify the writer does this have any effect on your judgement about the usefulness of this site? | - |
Does the institutional affiliation have any effect on your judgement about this site.? | Yes |
Why is this material here? | To provide information for the readers, from the readers. |
Is the purpose of this page indicated clearly in a prominent place? | Yes, through a link |
Is there any evident bias in the information at this site? | Yes |
Does the reason for this have any influence on your judgement about the usefulness of this site? | The matter of whether the information on Wikipedia is accurate is very sketchy. There have been debates about this issue and Wikipedia believes it's method is reasonable. |
Can I do a cross check? | Other resources anywhere |
Do I have any doubts about the accuracy of the material? | Yes |
If so, is there any way I can cross-check the accuracy of the information? | Books and other websites are the first places I'll look to to verify the information's accuracy. |
Is the information available anywhere else? | Encyclopedias On the Internet. |
Would it have been easier to get the information in some other way? | Maybe, but it's very conveinient to just look it up on this website. |
Does the site include links to other sites? | Yes |
Is there any selection process for the links? | Yes |
Are the links organised (i.e. by subject category)? | Yes |
Are the links described? | Yes |
Are the links all still active? | No, but most are and the ones that are not are correctly quickly. |
Do the links seem relevant to the subject of the web page? | Yes |
Is the page only viewable by a specific browser or release of browser? | No |
Is the site often busy and difficult to access? | No |
Does the page download in a reasonable time? | Yes |
Does it include any large graphics or files which take a long time to download? | In some places, but not all. |
Is it organised in a way that makes it easy to navigate? | Yes, but it is slightly cluttered, and to read through it the info you want to read sometimes takes paitience. |
Are the navigational links clear? | Yes. |
Do you have to scroll through the entire document to find information you want? | Yes |
Is there any provision for searching the site? | Yes |
Is the page viewable by a text-based browser only? | Yes |
Do all the graphics have a text explanation? | Yes |
Does the design complement the content? | Yes |
No comments:
Post a Comment